Is The Bakuchiol Plant Endangered? Bakuchiol vs Retinol Part Two

I have a very popular post on Science and Skincare titled Bakuchiol Vs Retinol but after seeing a post by one of my favourite dermatologists RanellaMD about the same topic, I got to thinking about one essential component of the comparison that was missing – sustainability.

Sustainability is one of the main reasons people want to seek alternatives for their beloved skincare products/ingredients. Is it good for the environment? How many air-miles does it take to bring all these ingredients together in a factory? Is the plant commercially farmed?

Shouldn’t we be taking these things into consideration given the state of the planet?

The big problem, that unfortunately I’ve seen firsthand, is that brands have the ability to markets themselves as ‘sustainable’ whilst not actually doing anything sustainable. This is because terms like ‘natural’ ‘sustainable’ and ‘clean’ aren’t very regulated.

That’s pretty much the case everywhere in the world. There aren’t governing bodies that can check these things for every product a brand makes.

There is already a big misconception that natural brands and sustainable brands go hand in hand but how can that be if they’re taking wild plants to use them in their products and not replacing them?

Surely, it makes more sense that a brand that uses synthetic ingredients is more sustainable because they don’t take from the planet? Although, then they wouldn’t be considered natural.

As a consumer how do we know the answer to any of these things? The answer right now, at least, is we don’t.

Sustainability is one of the biggest categories to think about when it comes to bakuchiol vs retinol and should be a big factor in your decision making because one is synthetically made and one is harvested in the wild.

Yes, that’s right. The babchi plant that is responsible for creating many beloved bakuchiol products is not commercially farmed, according to this 2017 article.

The article describes that fact that while the babchi plant (Psoralea corylifolia) has a diverse range of properties including; antimicrobial, antibacterial, anti-fungal and anti-inflammatory it is being overexploited and taken from their natural habitat as a result of their huge demand in the modern market. They are disappearing.

Conclusion

The fact is that it is incredible hard to navigate the ‘clean’ side of the beauty industry – whatever that means to you, but what we do know for sure is that in this comparison bakuchiol doesn’t seem to be the more sustainable option.

Now, that’s not to discredit it’s uses, as we saw in my last post on this topic it has many and can hold it’s own to retinol. Bakuchiol is especially useful for pregnant women and those prone to sensitivity but when it comes to sustainability there is a clear winner and it doesn’t start with B.

Read more

  • Is Tretinoin A Retinol?
    Is Tretinoin A Retinol? Well, in today’s article you’ll get a very straight forward answer that will help you distinguish whether or not you should use it. So.. Is Tretinoin A Retinol? No. Tretinoin is not a retinol but it is a retinoid. Retinoids are a family of vitamin A derivatives, which work in a…
  • In Conversation With Dr Sohere Roked, Organicup Head Of Brand Soo Cieszynska and Knude Society CEO Emma Brown 
    Three weeks ago the Lone Design Club held an event at their Chelsea Pop Up in South London. The event was about everything wellness, including all things sexual and was jam-packed with expert speakers from Organicup to The Knude Society. Today, all the panellists talk to Science and Skincare about wellness. Dr Sohere Roked, is…
  • Retin A Strengths
    Retin A strengths. This isn’t really a question because Retin A is just retinoid acid. Another name for this is Tretinoin. Tretinoin is a medication given to those suffering from severe acne. They are both retinoid acid, the strongest retinoid available. That’s why you need a prescription to get your hands on them. To make…
  • What Skincare Products Should I Use Quiz
    Putting a skincare routine together is hard work. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. This is precisely why I’ve created the ‘What Skincare Products Should I Use’ quiz. Hopefully this will make it a little easier for you to distinguish which products you need to change/add to your routine. The way it works is simple.…
  • PCOS Skincare Tips For Your Best Skin
    PCOS skincare is a tricky subject because it feels like it’s out of your control. Many people who suffer from Polycystic Ovary Syndrome suffer with skin issues, like acne. Click here to read more on acne treatments. The good news? You can tackle it and you are in control of your skin’s health. What is…

2 thoughts

    1. I actually haven’t done much research on this ingredient but I can imagine it will be endangered soon if brands aren’t sensible about how much they use. It would also be useful to know if brands can replace the sources they use!

Leave a Reply